Enterprise Fleet Management, 99.99% Uptime
Real-time GPS every second, 200+ integrations- 99.99% platform uptime guarantee
- 1-second GPS updates for precise tracking
- 200+ integrations with TMS, ERP, and business systems
Stay compliant with the FMCSA mandate while getting the most from your ELD investment. We've tested the top electronic logging devices to help owner-operators and small fleets find reliable, easy-to-use solutions.
By Small Fleet HQ | Published
| Provider | Price/mo | Contract | Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SamsaraBest Enterprise Platform | $27-33 | — | 4.4/ 5 | View PlansFMCSA-compliant devices |
| MotiveBest Value Features | $20-25 | — | 4.2/ 5 | View PlansFMCSA-compliant devices |
| BigRoadBest Budget Option | $19.99 | Month-to-month flexibilit | 4.0/ 5 | View PlansFMCSA-compliant devices |
| Garmin eLogBest No-Subscription | $249.99 | — | 4.0/ 5 | View PlansFMCSA-compliant devices |
*ELD pricing and features may vary. All devices listed are FMCSA-registered. Contact providers for current pricing.
The ELD mandate changed trucking forever when it went into full effect. Every commercial motor vehicle that requires a logbook now needs an electronic logging device, no exceptions. But not all ELDs are created equal, and the wrong choice can cost you time, money, and headaches during roadside inspections.
I've seen drivers struggling with clunky devices that freeze at the worst moments. I've talked to fleet owners who bought cheap ELDs only to replace them within a year. This guide helps you avoid those mistakes by breaking down what actually matters when picking an ELD for your operation.
An Electronic Logging Device automatically records driving time and Hours of Service data by connecting to your truck's engine. It replaces paper logs with digital records that transfer directly to enforcement officers during inspections. The FMCSA mandates ELDs to improve road safety and reduce paperwork-related violations.
Here's how it works. The ELD hardware plugs into your vehicle's diagnostic port, usually the 9-pin or 6-pin connector in the cab. It monitors engine status to detect when the vehicle is moving. That data syncs with a driver app on a smartphone or tablet where you manage your logs, record duty status changes, and handle inspections.
For most drivers, the ELD runs in the background. Your job is keeping your status current (driving, on-duty, sleeper berth, off-duty) and reviewing your logs for accuracy before certifying them.
The mandate applies to most commercial motor vehicle drivers who are required to keep Records of Duty Status. If you operate a vehicle with a gross vehicle weight rating over 10,000 pounds, carry hazardous materials requiring placards, or transport passengers for compensation, you likely need an ELD.
Some exemptions exist. Short-haul drivers operating within 150 air miles who return to their starting location daily may qualify for exemption. Drivers of vehicles manufactured before 2000 can continue using paper logs. Driveaway-towaway operators moving vehicles as cargo also get exemptions in certain situations.
If you're unsure whether you need an ELD, the safe answer is yes. The fines for non-compliance far exceed the cost of any ELD device.
ELDs automatically capture several data points required for compliance.
Engine Power Status: The ELD knows when your engine is on or off. This determines when automatic duty status changes can occur.
Vehicle Motion: Using engine data, the ELD detects when the vehicle is moving. Movement above 5 mph for a specified time triggers automatic driving status.
Miles Driven: The device records odometer readings or calculates distance traveled, crucial for IFTA reporting and log accuracy.
Engine Hours: Total engine operation time gets tracked, helping validate your hours of service calculations.
Location Data: GPS coordinates are recorded at specific intervals and during duty status changes, providing a breadcrumb trail of your trip.
Driver Identification: The system logs which driver is operating the vehicle, supporting team driving and slip-seating operations.
Beyond basic compliance, your ELD affects your daily workflow and bottom line. Here's what separates good ELDs from frustrating ones.
Reliability: A device that crashes, loses connection, or fails during inspections creates problems you don't need. Look for proven hardware with solid reviews from actual truckers.
Ease of Use: You'll interact with this device every day. Complicated interfaces waste time and increase the chance of errors. The best ELDs let drivers focus on driving, not fighting technology.
Inspection Mode: When DOT pulls you over, you need to transfer or display your logs quickly and correctly. Test this feature before you need it at a weigh station.
Support Quality: Problems happen. When your ELD acts up at 2 AM in the middle of nowhere, can you reach help? 24/7 support isn't a luxury in trucking.
Additional Features: Many ELDs now include GPS tracking, IFTA reporting, dashcams, and fleet management tools. These extras can consolidate your technology stack and provide additional value.
Every ELD vendor promises compliance and ease of use. Here's how to evaluate them objectively.
FMCSA Registration: Only use ELDs on the FMCSA's registered device list. Unregistered devices won't pass inspection, period. Verify registration status before purchasing.
Hardware Quality: Cheap devices fail in extreme temperatures and vibration. Commercial trucking is hard on equipment. Read reviews about durability and reliability in real-world conditions.
App Compatibility: Check that the driver app works with your smartphone or tablet. Some ELDs require specific devices, while others support iOS and Android broadly.
Cellular Coverage: ELDs rely on cellular connections to sync data. Ask about coverage and what happens when you're in dead zones. Good systems store data locally and sync when connectivity returns.
Contract Terms: Some providers require long-term contracts with early termination penalties. Others offer month-to-month flexibility. Know what you're committing to.
Total Cost: Factor in hardware costs, monthly subscription fees, and any per-feature charges. The cheapest upfront option isn't always the best value.
Most quality ELD providers offer these capabilities.
Learning from others' mistakes can save you significant frustration.
Unassigned Driving Time: When the truck moves without a logged driver, it creates unassigned time that must be accounted for. Train yourself to log in before moving the vehicle, even for short moves.
Malfunctions: Know your ELD's malfunction indicators and what to do when they appear. You have 8 days to get malfunctions repaired and must carry paper logs as backup during that period.
Data Transfer Failures: Practice transferring logs before an actual inspection. Fumbling with technology while an officer waits makes a bad impression and wastes time.
Edits and Annotations: Legitimate log edits are allowed, but excessive changes raise red flags. Annotate edits properly and keep them reasonable. Your ELD stores edit history.
Personal Conveyance Misuse: Using personal conveyance to extend driving time is a violation. Understand the rules around PC and use it only when legitimately off-duty and not under dispatch.
Our owner operator starter stack covers ELDs, insurance, factoring, and everything else you need, organized into three budget tiers.
Owner operator starter pack →ELD pricing typically ranges from $15 to $50 per month per vehicle, plus hardware costs of $100-$500 upfront. Some providers waive hardware fees with subscription commitments. Total first-year costs generally run $300-$800 per truck depending on features and contract terms.
Most modern ELDs are designed for self-installation, taking 10-30 minutes to complete. The hardware typically plugs into your diagnostic port with no special tools required. That said, if you're not comfortable with basic electrical connections, professional installation is available from most providers.
You'll display your current day's log plus the previous 7 days on your device screen or transfer the data electronically to the officer. Most drivers choose screen display. The officer reviews your hours, looks for violations, and checks that your device is registered. Having practiced this process reduces stress.
Document the malfunction and notify your carrier within 24 hours. You must reconstruct your logs on paper and continue using paper logs until the device is repaired. You have 8 days to get the ELD fixed or replaced. Carry paper log supplies as backup at all times.
ELDs record location at duty status changes and periodically during driving. When you're off-duty and the vehicle isn't moving, most devices minimize tracking. However, fleet management features may track vehicles continuously for security and operational purposes. Understand your device's tracking behavior and your company's policies.
Most ELD providers offer apps that work on personal smartphones. However, your phone becomes part of your compliance equipment. Battery life, storage space, and data connectivity all matter. Some drivers prefer dedicated tablets to keep personal and work devices separate. Check app requirements before committing.
Paper logs are the traditional handwritten method, now only allowed for exempt drivers. AOBRDs (Automatic On-Board Recording Devices) were an older electronic standard that's been phased out since December 2019. ELDs meeting the current FMCSA technical specifications are now required for all non-exempt commercial drivers.
Team drivers can share a single ELD device but maintain separate driver profiles. When switching drivers, log out and have the new driver log in. The ELD tracks which driver is operating the vehicle at any time. Co-drivers can manage their off-duty or sleeper berth status while the other driver operates the vehicle.