Trucking Specialist
The Trucking Insurance Specialists Since 1956
Dedicated exclusively to trucking for nearly 70 years- 100% trucking-focused since 1956
- Award-winning claims service
- Extensive safety and training resources
Educational ContentNot Insurance Advice
We provide educational information to help you understand trucking insurance options. We may receive compensation from partners when you request quotes.
5 Best Trucking Insurance for New Authority Carriers (2026)
Getting affordable trucking insurance with new authority is one of the toughest hurdles for first-time carriers. Most insurers price new operators as high-risk, pushing quotes to $12,000-$25,000 a year — but the carriers below treat new authorities fairly and help you get through that costly first stretch.
By Small Fleet HQ | Updated
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Company | Insures New Authority | Monthly Premium Range | Quote Speed | Coverage Types | Down Payment | Telematics Discount |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
#1 Great West Casualty | $1,050 - $2,700+ | 1-3 days (agent) | Liability, PD, Cargo, NTL, GL, OA, TI, Umbrella | 15-25% of annual premium | ||
#2 Progressive Commercial | $1,000 - $2,500+ | Minutes (online) | Liability, PD, Cargo, NTL, GL, OA | 10-20% of annual premium | Up to 10% | |
#3 Cover Whale | $900 - $2,300+ | Minutes (online) | Liability, PD, Cargo, NTL, GL | 10-15% of annual premium | Up to 30% | |
#4 HDVI | $950 - $2,400+ | Same day (online) | Liability, PD, Cargo, NTL, GL | 10-20% of annual premium | Up to 20% | |
#5 Nirvana Insurance | $625-$1,333 | Online - instant | Liability, Physical, Cargo, NTL, GL, OA | Varies | AI and computer vision - risk-based pricing | |
#6 Sentry Insurance | $1,000 - $2,600+ | 1-3 days (agent) | Liability, PD, Cargo, NTL, GL, OA, TI, Umbrella | 15-25% of annual premium | Safety program discounts | |
#7 Lancer Insurance | $650-$1,250 | Agent - 1-3 days | Liability, Physical, Cargo, NTL, GL, OA, Trailer | Varies | ||
#8 OOIDA Insurance | $625-$1,167 | Agent - 1-3 days | Liability, Physical, Cargo, NTL, OA | Varies | ||
#9 Northland Insurance | $800 - $2,000+ | 1-3 days (agent) | Liability, PD, Cargo, NTL, GL | 15-20% of annual premium |
In-Depth Reviews
Online Quote Leader
Name Your Price on Commercial Truck Insurance
Get a free quote in minutes - new authority welcome- Online quote system available 24/7
- New authority and new entrant programs
- Smart Haul telematics discount program
Insurtech Innovator
AI-Powered Insurance for Safer Trucking
Up to 30% discount for safe drivers with real-time telematics- AI-powered risk assessment and pricing
- Real-time dashcam and ELD integration
- Up to 30% premium discount for safe drivers
Telematics Pioneer
Real-Time Telematics Insurance for Truckers
Monthly premium adjustments based on actual driving data- Real-time premium adjustments based on driving data
- Up to 20% monthly discount for safe driving
- ELD and telematics integration
AI Insurance Leader
AI-First Commercial Trucking Insurance
Computer vision technology for smarter risk assessment- AI and computer vision risk assessment
- Data-led underwriting for accurate pricing
- Real-time risk monitoring and alerts
Long-Term Stability
A+ Rated Trucking Insurance Since 1904
Over 30 years of trucking specialization with mutual company benefits- A+ AM Best rating maintained for 30+ years
- Mutual company structure (policyholder-owned)
- Dedicated trucking division since early 1990s
Owner-Operator Focus
Specialty Trucking Insurance Since 1985
Owner-operator specialists with industry expertise- Nearly 40 years focused on transportation
- Strong owner-operator program
- Passenger transportation expertise (bus, limousine)
Owner-Operator Advocacy
Insurance Built By Truckers, For Truckers
Member-exclusive rates with advocacy backing your business- Exclusive rates for OOIDA members
- Occupational accident coverage specialists
- Trucking advocacy organization backing
Regional Value Leader
Practical Trucking Coverage Built on Midwest Values
Competitive rates with straightforward coverage for working truckers- Travelers company backing
- Competitive pricing for standard risks
- Efficient underwriting process
Estimate Your Insurance Premium
Get a ballpark estimate of your trucking insurance costs based on your equipment and operating profile.
The FMCSA requires all for-hire interstate carriers to maintain a minimum of $750,000 in primary liability insurance, with proof filed via the BMC-91 form. Most brokers and shippers also require cargo insurance, and lenders mandate physical damage coverage on financed equipment. Meeting these requirements with new authority typically means a total annual insurance spend of $14,000 to $25,000 or more for a single truck. However, the market has shifted in recent years with insurtech companies offering telematics-based pricing that rewards safe driving from the start, rather than penalizing new operators with blanket high rates.
The most important thing to know as a new authority holder is that rates drop significantly -- typically 15-30% -- after your first two years of clean operating history. The carriers listed below are the ones we recommend for getting through that initial high-cost period. We ranked them based on their willingness to insure new authority carriers, premium affordability, speed of quoting and binding, breadth of coverage options, and the availability of discounts or programs that help new operators reduce costs faster.
Common Questions
How much does trucking insurance cost for new authority?
New authority trucking insurance typically costs between $12,000 and $25,000 per year for a single-truck operation, depending on coverage types, operating radius, commodities hauled, and your CDL experience. Primary liability alone usually runs $8,000 to $16,000 annually, with physical damage and cargo coverage adding another $4,000 to $10,000. These premiums are significantly higher than what experienced carriers pay because insurers view new operators as higher risk. However, rates typically drop 15-30% after your first two years of clean operating history.
Which insurance companies accept new authority carriers?
Several major insurers accept new authority carriers, though options are more limited than for experienced operators. Progressive Commercial is one of the most accessible, accepting carriers with zero operating history and offering online quotes. Great West Casualty has structured new authority programs with dedicated support. HDVI and Lancer Insurance accept CDL holders with as little as 6 months of experience. Cover Whale, Nirvana Insurance, Sentry Insurance, OOIDA Insurance, and Northland Insurance also write new authorities with varying experience requirements. In total, nine carriers on our list accept new authority holders. Companies like biBERK and National Indemnity require a minimum of 2 years operating authority and do not insure new entrants.
What is the minimum insurance required for a new trucking company?
The FMCSA requires all for-hire interstate trucking companies to carry a minimum of $750,000 in primary liability insurance for general freight, with the BMC-91 form filed as proof. Carriers hauling hazardous materials need $1 million to $5 million depending on the cargo. Beyond the federal minimum, most brokers and shippers require motor truck cargo insurance (typically $100,000 in coverage), and if you are financing your truck, your lender will require physical damage coverage. Many carriers also purchase non-trucking liability (bobtail), occupational accident, and general liability coverage for full protection.
How can I lower my insurance costs as a new carrier?
There are several proven strategies to reduce insurance costs as a new carrier. First, consider telematics-based insurers like Cover Whale or HDVI that reward safe driving with discounts up to 20-30%. Second, complete safety training courses -- carriers like Great West Casualty and Sentry offer premium discounts for safety program participation. Third, maintain a clean MVR and CSA score from day one. Fourth, choose a higher deductible on physical damage coverage to lower premiums. Fifth, shop multiple quotes since pricing varies significantly between carriers. Finally, bundle coverage types with a single insurer for multi-policy discounts. Your rates will drop most significantly after two years of clean operating history.
How long does it take to get trucking insurance with new authority?
The timeline depends on the insurer. Online-first carriers like Progressive Commercial and Cover Whale can provide preliminary quotes in minutes and bind coverage within 24-48 hours. Traditional insurers that work through agents -- such as Great West Casualty, Sentry Insurance, and Northland Insurance -- typically take 1-3 business days for a quote and another 1-2 days to bind. Most new authority holders should plan for 3-7 business days from first contact to having active coverage with FMCSA filings completed. Start the insurance process before your authority is granted, since you cannot operate legally until your BMC-91 filing is on record with the FMCSA.
When should I start shopping for insurance?
Start shopping for insurance as soon as you submit your MC authority application through the FMCSA MOTUS portal. The insurance filing process takes time, and your authority cannot go active without proof of insurance on file. Most insurance agents recommend starting the quoting process 2-4 weeks before you need coverage to begin. This gives you time to compare quotes and complete the application process.
What is a BMC-91 filing?
A BMC-91 is the form your insurance company files with the FMCSA proving that you have the required minimum liability coverage. Also called an MCS-90 endorsement, this filing must remain active with the FMCSA at all times for your authority to stay active. If your insurance lapses and the BMC-91 filing is removed, the FMCSA begins the process of revoking your authority. Your insurance company handles the filing, but you should verify it shows as active on the FMCSA SAFER website.
Can I get insurance with a new CDL and no experience?
Yes, but options are limited and expensive. Most standard trucking insurance markets require at least 2 years of CDL experience. Carriers with drivers who have less than 2 years of experience are placed in surplus lines markets where premiums are significantly higher. Some insurance programs specifically serve new drivers, but expect to pay 30-50% more than experienced operators until you build a track record.
Do I need insurance before my MC authority is active?
You need insurance bound and the BMC-91 filed with the FMCSA before your authority can go active. The insurance must be in force on the date your authority becomes active. Most carriers bind insurance coverage 1-2 days before their expected activation date. Your insurance agent can coordinate the timing of the BMC-91 filing with your authority activation.
What happens if my insurance lapses after getting authority?
An insurance lapse is one of the most serious compliance failures in trucking. When your insurance company notifies the FMCSA that your coverage has been cancelled, the FMCSA begins the authority revocation process. You must stop operating immediately. Reinstatement requires obtaining new insurance, having a new BMC-91 filed, and potentially reapplying for authority. Lapses also appear on your FMCSA record and can make future insurance more expensive.
Disclaimer: This section is for educational purposes only. Insurance requirements vary by state, cargo type, and operation. Always consult a licensed insurance agent who specializes in commercial trucking. Requirements and regulations referenced here were current as of early 2026 but are subject to change.
FMCSA Insurance Filing Requirements
The FMCSA sets minimum insurance coverage for all for-hire carriers. You must meet these requirements before your authority goes active.
Required Filings
BMC-91 (Form E) — Proof of Liability Insurance. Your insurance company files this directly with the FMCSA, proving you carry the required minimum liability coverage. This must remain on file continuously.
BMC-91X — Surety Bond Alternative. If you use a surety bond instead of traditional insurance for the FMCSA filing, the BMC-91X is the applicable form. Most carriers use traditional insurance (BMC-91).
Minimum Coverage by Cargo Type
| Cargo Type | Minimum Liability |
|---|---|
| General freight (non-hazmat) | $750,000 |
| Household goods | $750,000 |
| Oil transport (non-bulk) | $1,000,000 |
| Hazardous materials | $1,000,000 – $5,000,000 |
These are FMCSA minimums per 49 CFR Part 387. Many brokers and shippers require $1,000,000 in liability regardless of cargo type. Carrying $1,000,000 opens more freight opportunities even if you only haul general freight.
Additional Coverage You Need
Beyond the FMCSA minimum, most carriers need the following:
- Cargo insurance: $100,000 is the standard minimum. Many brokers require it, and it protects you from claims for damaged or lost freight.
- Physical damage (comp and collision): Covers your truck and trailer. Required by lenders if you have a loan.
- Bobtail or non-trucking liability: Covers your truck when not under dispatch.
- Occupational accident insurance: Covers medical expenses and lost income if you are injured on the job. Not required by FMCSA but strongly recommended for owner operators.
What New Authority Insurance Actually Costs
New authority carriers pay significantly more than established operators. Here are realistic ranges based on single-truck owner operators with general freight authority.
First-Year Cost Ranges
| Coverage | Annual Range |
|---|---|
| Primary liability ($1M) | $8,000 – $14,000 |
| Cargo insurance ($100K) | $800 – $2,000 |
| Physical damage | $2,000 – $5,000 |
| Bobtail/NTL | $400 – $800 |
| Occupational accident | $800 – $1,200 |
| Total first-year estimate | $12,000 – $23,000 |
Why New Authority Costs More
Insurance companies price based on risk data. New authorities are higher risk because:
- Approximately 30% of new trucking companies fail within 2 years
- New carriers have no verifiable safety history with the FMCSA
- No claims history means no proof of safe operations
- New operators are statistically more likely to have incidents
After 18-24 months of clean operations, most carriers see meaningful rate reductions at their first renewal. The improvement continues as your authority ages and your safety record builds.
Getting Insured: Step by Step
1. Start Early
Begin the insurance shopping process 2-4 weeks before you need coverage. Do not wait until the day your authority is ready.
2. Work with Specialized Agents
Use insurance agents who specialize in commercial trucking. General agents usually cannot access the markets that insure new authorities. Trucking-specific agents know which carriers accept new authority risks and can quote multiple markets quickly.
Get at least 3 quotes from different agents. Rates vary dramatically between insurers for new authority risks.
3. Have Your Information Ready
Agents need your MC number and USDOT number, CDL information for all drivers, truck VIN and equipment details, planned operating radius and cargo types, prior insurance history (if any), and loss history for the past 3-5 years.
4. Understand What You Are Buying
Review the declarations page carefully. Verify coverage limits, deductibles, and any exclusions. Ask about when the BMC-91 will be filed with the FMCSA, monthly versus annual payment options, cancellation terms and notice requirements, and what triggers a mid-term rate increase.
5. Bind Coverage and Verify Filing
Once you select a policy, bind coverage and confirm that your agent files the BMC-91 with the FMCSA. Verify the filing appears on the FMCSA SAFER website within a few days. Your authority cannot go active without this filing.
Surviving the Expensive First Two Years
Budget Conservatively
Build insurance into your startup costs from day one. Do not be surprised by the premium. If $15,000-$20,000 in annual insurance is not workable in your business plan, your revenue projections may need adjustment.
Avoid Lapses at All Costs
An insurance lapse on your FMCSA record makes future insurance even more expensive and can result in authority revocation. If you are struggling to make premium payments, talk to your agent before the policy cancels.
Build Your Safety Record
Every month of clean operations without accidents or violations improves your renewal position. CSA scores directly influence insurance pricing. Maintain clean inspections and use your ELD properly.
Plan for Renewal
At 10-12 months, start shopping for renewal quotes. Do not automatically renew with the same carrier. Competition for your business increases as your authority ages, and shopping around at renewal can produce significant savings.
For strategies to reduce your insurance costs over time, see our guide on lowering insurance premiums. For the full startup sequence including insurance timing, see our starting a trucking business guide. Clean driving, proper maintenance, and operational discipline are what make you insurable at competitive rates.